Sunday, August 3, 2014

Proposal Problem Statement: Determining the correct punishment for Ray Rice

            On July 24, 2014, Ray Rice was handed a two game suspension from the National Football League for violation of its player conduct policy.  This is the result of a surveillance video from a casino in New Jersey arising last February.  The video shows Ray Rice dragging his unconscious wife out of an elevator after he beat her.  After the length of the suspension was released, controversy arose regarding its short length.  The mere two game suspension was compared to the recent Josh Gordon season-long (16 games) suspension for testing positive for marijuana.  Many believed that domestic abuse, especially to the extent of beating someone senseless, was much worse than smoking marijuana.  It is important to note that Josh Gordon was a two-time offender of the league’s drug policy.  However, it is still a minimum four game suspension for every first time offender to the drug policy, which includes marijuana.  Another comparable suspension involves the Oakland Raiders and former Ohio State quarterback Terrelle Prior.  Prior received a five game suspension from the NFL regarding allegations from his college years of signing memorabilia for money.  The third, and final, suspension to compare this allegation to involves the Richie Incognito of the Miami Dolphins situation.  Incognito was suspended for three months for the bullying of teammate Jonathan Martin.  It is questionable whether this situation was worse than Ray Rice’s domestic abuse case, but the much larger length of the suspension for Incognito is the important part.  Smoking marijuana and signing memorabilia for money while in college are certainly not considered as bad as domestic abuse.  Smoking marijuana and paying college athletes are rules that may be demolished by the United States government and the NCAA.  However, a man beating a woman is considered both immoral and appropriately illegal.  This is why there is so much controversy over Ray Rice’s two game suspension compared to previous longer, less immoral, suspensions.

No comments:

Post a Comment